The 10 Best Cake Shops in Illinois!

Cake is often the grand finale of a special occasion. From weddings to graduation parties to birthdays celebrations, finding the right cake is essential. Illinois’ cake shops are staffed by expert bakers and cake artists prepared to customize something exceptional for you. For the freshest, finest cakes, head to these 10 great shops in Illinois! 

1. Incredibly Delicious, Springfield, IL

At incredibly delicious, the name speaks for itself. Located in a historic home, this traditional French bakery specializes in the finest specialty cakes for all occasions. Their cakes are baked with the finest ingredients and coated with a delicious buttercream frosting. Customers love the friendly service and beautiful setting of this cake shop. 

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Incredibly Delicious (@incdelcakes) on

2. Creative Cakes Bakery & Cafe, Naperville and Tinley Park, IL

The sky’s the limit at Creative Cakes Bakery. They are known for their outrageous custom cakes, which are both delicious and aesthetically appealing. The customer service is also great—the staff members are very knowledgeable and helpful. They make sure the customers are always satisfied. 

3. Trefzger's Bakery, Peoria Heights, IL

Known as Central Illinois’ oldest bakery, Trefzger’s Bakery has been making scrumptious cakes since 1861! Whether you want an everyday cupcake or special custom cake, this Peoria tradition is your go-to bakery. The excellent service and fresh baked goods make this bakery worth checking out. 

4. Larry's House of Cakes, Carbondale and Marion, IL

This popular Southern Illinois bakery offers excellent cakes made from scratch by caring people. Whether you want a designer cake or a dozen cupcakes, Larry’s House of Cakes is the place to go. They are very professional and offer quick turnaround times on orders. 

5. Cali Girl Cakes, Bolingbrook, IL

Cali Girl Cakes is an award-winning bakery featuring specialty cupcakes and custom cakes. The cakes contain just the perfect amount of sweetness and are absolutely scrumptious. Customers also appreciate the courteous service and ambience of the bakery. 

6. Aurelio's Bake Shop, Sterling, IL

Aurelio’s Bake Shop is a local favorite because of the fantastic cakes, which are always moist, delicious, and nicely decorated. The accommodating staff works hard to ensure customers are happy with their orders. Whatever your vision, you can count on Aurelio’s to deliver and exceed your expectations. 

7. Anna Baking Company, Anna, IL

The cakes at Anna Baking Company are almost too cute to eat! They’re decorated so beautifully and taste amazing. It seems this bakery has a keen sense of what their customers really want because they exceed customer expectations. Their cakes also very affordable. 

8. Angie's Sugar Buzz Bakery, Sandwich, IL

This laid-back bakery has a passion for making high-quality pastries from scratch. They offer a wide variety of sweets including cupcakes and cakes, each made with care and customized for any occasion. The owner really cares about providing the best service and flavors in her baked goods. 

9. Berkemann's Baker's Dozen, New Baden, IL

Taste a slice of heaven at Berkemann’s Baker’s Dozen. This local gem is known for their scrumptious cakes and reasonable prices. Customers love the friendly service and highly recommend the butter cakes and sheet cakes. This is one of the best bakeries in Southern Illinois. 

10. The Village Bakery, Oregon, IL

This small-town bakery is so friendly, welcoming, and just downright cute. They offer a great selection of pastries including cupcakes and cake slices. Customers love the freshness and taste of the cakes and appreciate the drive-through, as well. 

Illinois Search
View more Illinois Bakeries and Pastry Shops.
Find Bakeries and Pastry Shops Near You
Select a Illinois town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you