The 10 Best Places for Milkshakes in Illinois!

Milkshakes are iconic to the Midwest, and Illinoisans love to indulge in frozen treats. In Illinois, you’ll find the best milkshakes at the family-owned, often inconspicuous joints scattered throughout the rural areas. Many of these milkshake places have been in business for decades, providing locals with the best desserts served by caring, friendly people who are dedicated to their customers. 

1. Sidney Dairy Barn, Sidney, IL

Sidney Dairy Barn is known for their old-fashioned tasting ice cream made with fresh ingredients. They offer many ice cream flavors, many of which are fruit-based for those fruit lovers out there. Their milkshakes are very popular and customers love the pineapple and vanilla shakes. This joint is always changing their flavors, adding more to provide variety. 

2. Krekel's Custard, Multiple locations

Although known primarily for their thin and crispy-edged hamburgers, Krekel’s Custard offers handmade milkshakes that make you a customer for life. Their shakes are available in many flavors such as marshmallow, peanut butter, orange, root beer, and several others. Patrons appreciate the fast, friendly service year after year. Find locations in Decatur, Grandview, Mt. Zion, and Pawnee. 

3. Scooter's Frozen Custard, Chicago, IL

Scooter’s Frozen Custard is a popular join and highly recognized for their Boston Shake. They also offer many unique and season flavors to keep their customers engaged throughout the year. Customers love the authentic flavors and consistent high quality of the menu items. 

4. Mindy's Hot Chocolate Restaurant and Dessert Bar, Chicago, IL

Although known for their decadent hot chocolates, Mindy’s Hot Chocolate Dessert Bar also offers delicious milkshakes in six decadent flavors. Chef Mindy Segal has a passion for desserts and puts great attention into every treat. The cozy ambiance and attentive service make this renowned restaurant a Chicago favorite. 

5. Ice Cream Shack of Sunnyland, Washington, IL

Ice Cream Shack is a no-frills ice cream joint and local favorite. Although you may have to wait in a long line, you can expect to be impressed with their delicious shakes, large portions, and friendly service. Keep in mind they only accept cash. 

6. Hamburger Heaven, Elmhurst, IL

Hamburger Heaven is an old-fashioned walk-up hamburger joint with some of the best shakes in the area. Customer recommend the chocolate caramel cake shake and root beer shake, but you can’t go wrong with any of their shakes. This joint hasn’t changed for decades and the locals appreciate the old-school atmosphere. 


A post shared by Matt Arauz Photography (@the_man_with_the_golden_camera) on

7. Lim's Ice Cream Shoppe, Galesburg, IL

Known for their 44 ice cream flavors, Lim’s Ice Cream Shoppe has been serving delicious treats since 1988. Patrons drive for miles to grab their favorite flavors and experience the friendly customer service. Their shakes, cones, ice cream cakes, and other treats are all worth trying. 

8. Red Bicycle Ice Cream, Urbana, IL

If you want the freshest milkshakes featuring locally-sourced ingredients, check out Red Bicycle Ice Cream in Urbana. This ice cream shop give out free samples of their many flavors and offers friendly customer service. Their milkshakes are handcrafted and some of the best in the area. 

9. Jarling’s Custard Cup, Champaign, IL

Voted the number one dessert in Champaign, Jarling’s Custard Cup is a local favorite because of their delicious frozen treats. They make small batches using only the finest ingredients from local dairy farms. Their milkshakes also meet customer expectations as does their attentive service. 

10. The Custard Stand, Sesser, IL

This family-owned custard stand has been a local hot spot since 1949. The Custard Stand is known for their awesome desserts including milkshakes, orange sherbet, banana splits, and much more. Their customers will wait in lines trailing down the block just to order their delicious frozen treats. 

Illinois Search
Grab a Milkshake Near You
Select a Illinois town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you